Home | Contact Us |
Sarasota Restaurant Reviews
Sarasota dining guide, events, nightlife

Restaurant
Cuisine

American
Amish
Asian
Barbeque
Cajun
Chinese
Eclectic
European
French
German
Greek
Indian
Italian
Japanese
Latin
Mediterranean
Mexican
Middle Eastern
New American
Pacific Island
Peruvian
Seafood
Spanish
Thai
Vietnamese

Restaurant
Style

Bistro
Breakfast
BYOB
Casual
Deli
Dog Friendly
Family
Fine Dining
Frugal Dining
Happy Hour
Health
Lunch
Organic
Pizza
Pub
Steakhouse
Sushi
Waterfront
Zone - Anna Maria Island
Zone - Bradenton
Zone - Burns Court
Zone - Downtown
Zone - Gulf Gate
Zone - Holmes Beach
Zone - Lakewood Ranch
Zone - Longboat Key
Zone - Nokomis
Zone - Northport
Zone - Osprey
Zone - Palmetto
Zone - Rosemary District
Zone - Siesta Key
Zone - Southgate
Zone - Southgate S
Zone - Southside Village
Zone - St. Armands
Zone - Towles Court
Zone - University Park
Zone - Venice

Old Salty Dog, City Island

Old Salty Dog, City Island
1601 Ken Thompson Parkway
Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: 941-388-4311


7
Food Presentation Decor Service Value
7 6 7 7.5 7.5

“Old Florida,” Family Friendly, Fun

An iconic, old Florida styled restaurant located on City Island, The Salty Dog is all about fun.  The City Island location (there is another Salty Dog located in Siesta Key Village) offers sweeping views of New Pass, the Longboat Key Bridge, and the Bay.  With most of its seating open-aired, The Old Salty Dog is the perfect spot to have a drink or casual meal while soaking up some sun and enjoying a great view. In fact, even on cooler days, you can get protection from the wind and still be outside soaking in the whole experience.  You can even bring your dog!

The menu is a casual collection of soups, starters, salads, sandwiches, seafood, burgers, dogs, and specialty items like the Fully Loaded Salty Dog as seen on Man vs. Food. For our meals we chose the following:

The House Salad with Grilled Grouper:  The BIG salad, romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, croutons, and grilled grouper $14.90
A large salad with very fresh ingredients.
City Island Po’ Boy:  Fried shrimp and oysters served on a toasted Ciabatta roll, garnished with lettuce and tomato and a spicy Creole sauce on the side $12.95
A good sized roll filled with crispy shrimp and sweet oysters, the Creole sauce was nicely spiced and added a true Cajun flavor.
Oysters on the Half Shell:  Raw or steamed with lemons and cocktail sauce. 1/2 dozen or full dozen/market price.
Large, briney Texas Gulf oysters served with fresh cocktail sauce; delicious.
Traditional Fish and Chips:  Filet of cold water fish, deep fried in our special beer batter.  Served with a mound of golden french fries. $12.95
Two large fish filets, crispy golden batter, moist and flaky.
New Pass Mussels:  PEI mussels steamed and tossed in garlic butter and served with toast points 1.5lbs $9.95, 3lbs. $17.95, 5lbs. $30.95
Fresh, sweet steamed mussels with a nicely seasoned garlic broth.
Mahi Mahi Wrap:  Grilled mahi mahi in a warm flour tortilla with fresh romaine, and mango salsa. $14.95
Fresh and moist mahi mahi, mango salsa added just the right amount of sweetness.
The Loaded Salty Dog:  A quarter pound hot dog dipped in beer batter deep fried to a golden brown. Loaded with all the toppings, (as seen on the Travel Channel’s Man vs Food.) American, Swiss, Cheddar and Pepper Jack cheeses, sauerkraut, bacon, grilled onions and grilled mushrooms. $13.95
Certainly not health food! Incredibly decadent, layers of flavor, not your everyday dining experience but worth a try.

The Old Salty Dog serves a wide variety of special drinks, beer, wine, and soft drinks.  Service was very quick, efficient, friendly and attentive.

With a broad menu, on the water setting, and a very friendly casual atmosphere, The Old Salty Dog is a “go to” place to grab a drink and a quick bite.

SRQ Reviews, the restaurant guide you need to find the best dining in Sarasota, Florida.

The Old Salty Dog on Urbanspoon


Insider Tips
If you want to try the fully loaded Salty Dog, order all the toppings individually, and save $1.00.

Categories: American, Seafood
Styles: Casual, Dog Friendly, Happy Hour, Lunch, Pub, Waterfront

Breakfast: N/A
Lunch: Monday - Sunday 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Dinner: Monday - Sunday 5:00 PM to 9:30 PM
Late night: Friday - Saturday 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM
Entrees: $11.95 - $20.95
Reservations: Not Available
Open Air Space: Yes
Date Reviewed: 01-02-2011
Exceptions: 

Click here for directions or a larger map.

URL: http://www.theoldsaltydog.com


Back to Review Listings



 
   

 SRQ Reviews

Best restaurant reviews in Sarasota Florida
Follow Me on Pinterest

Follow SRQ on
Follow SRQ on Facebook
Follow SRQ on Twitter 

Be part of the SRQ Review Network
Be part of the
SRQ Network
put our badge on your blog or website

Banner Photos by
Marcus Urban