Home | Contact Us |
Sarasota Restaurant Reviews
Sarasota dining guide, events, nightlife


Middle Eastern
New American
Pacific Island


Dog Friendly
Fine Dining
Frugal Dining
Happy Hour
Zone - Anna Maria Island
Zone - Bradenton
Zone - Burns Court
Zone - Downtown
Zone - Gulf Gate
Zone - Holmes Beach
Zone - Lakewood Ranch
Zone - Longboat Key
Zone - Nokomis
Zone - Northport
Zone - Osprey
Zone - Palmetto
Zone - Rosemary District
Zone - Siesta Key
Zone - Southgate
Zone - Southgate S
Zone - Southside Village
Zone - St. Armands
Zone - Towles Court
Zone - University Park
Zone - Venice

Cafe Gabbiano Restaurant

Cafe Gabbiano Restaurant
5104 Ocean Boulevard
Siesta Key, FL 34242
Phone: 941-349-1423

Food Presentation Decor Service Value
8 7.5 7.5 7.5 6.5

Cafe Gabbiano:  Wine and Food, Italian Style...

One step inside Café Gabbiano, and you know this is not your typical Italian restaurant. Yes, it does serve classic Italian cuisine, and yes, there are some vines and empty wine bottles as part of the décor. However, Café Gabbiano is more.

A longstanding casual Italian restaurant on Siesta Key, Café Gabbiano became a fixture on the island. Originally owned and operated by Chef Pietro Migliaccio, the restaurant changed hands a little more than a year ago. Now owned and operated by Marc Grimaud and business partner Peter Tracy, Café Gabbiano is a casual, yet upscale Italian trattoria. With indoor and outdoor seating, space for private parties and a cozy dining room, this large space has a warm, quiet and refined feel. It’s the type of place where diners could be dressed in shorts or a little black dress – casually upscale.

With an emphasis on wine, Café Gabbiano’s dining experience becomes more than just a meal. With more than 200 wine selections, the staff is always ready to help select the perfect food and wine pairing. In addition to the extensive wine list, there are ample choices on the dinner menu as well. With a wide selection of salads, appetizers, meat, seafood and pastas, making a singular choice from the dinner menu is a challenge. For our meals we chose the following:

Involtini di Asparagi:  Fresh asparagus wrapped with prosciutto di parma, gorgonzola and cream cheese. $12.95
Such a great combination of fresh crisp, salty, tangy and sweet.
Antipasti Misti:  Mixed appetizer platter with roasted gabbianoveggiesvegetables, bruschetta, mozzarella caprese.  $12.95
A very colorful presentation of marinated vegetables – tasty.
Insalata di Mare:  Shrimp, calamari, mussels and clams served over celery, with a lemon and oil dressing. $13.95
A great combination of fresh seafood; refreshing and tastes like summer.
Burrata:  Fresh Italian cheese made from mozzarella and cream, served with speck, fresh pesto and Italian bread.  $12.95
Full disclosure: burrata is definitely one of my favorites. It’s sweet, creamy and a great contrast to the slightly salty, smoky speck.
Ossobuco Ravioli:  Ravioli stuffed with braised veal. Prepared with homemade bolognese sauce.  $22.95
Rich, flavorful and absolutely delicious.
Gnocchi Bolognese:  Hand rolled gnocchi. Daily preparation.  $21.95
Well prepared, soft yet al dente and served with a rich meat sauce.
Scaloppine Mamma Lucia: Veal sauteed in marsala wine with fresh wild mushrooms and topped with eggplant and fresh mozzarella cheese. (One of the house specialties named after Mamma.)  $25.95
Layers of flavor are deep and rich. Tender, melt-in-your-mouth goodness.
Gamberoni di Ischia:  Gulf shrimp sauteed in olive oil, garlic, tomatoes and a touch of brandy, served over a bed of fresh spinach. $24.95
Very nice presentation, and a generous portion of shrimp … eight! The sweet tomatoes and fresh spinach created a light, flavorful dish.
Filet of Sole di Amalfi:  Lightly battered sole sauteed with lemon, butter and white wine. A light and delicious meal. $23.95
The portion was a good size, and the fish was fresh, sweet and complemented by the tangy lemon. The side of pasta was al dente, just the way we like it.
Truffled Allen Brothers Steak:  Ask about the cut and preparation of the day. Served with mushroom, risotto and the vegetable of the day.  $41.95.
Rich and tender, this fillet was melt-in-your-mouth delicious.
Filet of Grouper:  Locally caught white fish. Prepared special daily.  $29.95
We had locally caught red grouper prepared with sun dried tomatoes, spinach and capers in a white wine sauce.
Homemade Tiramisu:  $7.95
Creamy, sweet, luscious and homemade. Need I say more?
Mini Cannoli:  $7.95
A nice flaky and crunchy shell filled with an ever-so-slightly sweet cream.
Chocolate Ravioli:  A chocolate pasta dough filled with a chocolate hazelnut cream.  $7.95
Perhaps one of the greatest combinations known to man: chocolate and pasta. Can you imagine? It was outstanding.

In addition to their extensive wine list, Café Gabbiano also offers full bar service for pre or post dinner cocktails. The waitstaff is very friendly, attentive and accommodating.  On one occasion, we had a slightly longer-than-expected wait for the food, but the staff responded very professionally.

Café Gabbiano is not your everyday dining spot.  The food, wine, and setting are special. It’s the perfect place to celebrate with a nice bottle of wine and some great food.  I am not sure if good food makes wine taste better, or if good wine makes food taste better.  Whatever the case, Café Gabbiano has both!

SRQ Reviews, the restaurant guide you need to find the best dining in Sarasota, Florida.

Cafe Gabbiano on Urbanspoon

Insider Tips
First Friday of the Month:  Complimentary wine tasting.
"Siesta Hour":  5:00-6:30pm, $5 drinks and appetizers.  Late Night Happy Hour:  9:00-10:00pm.

Categories: Italian
Styles: Bistro, Happy Hour, Zone - Siesta Key

Breakfast: N/A
Lunch: N/A
Dinner: Monday-Sunday 4:00 PM to 10:00 PM
Late night: Friday-Saturday 4:00 PM to 11:00 PM
Entrees: $17.95-$41.95
Reservations: Yes
Open Air Space: Yes
Date Reviewed: 12-10-2013
Exceptions:  Sunday Brunch 10:00-2:00

Click here for directions or a larger map.

URL: http://www.cafegabbiano.com

Back to Review Listings


 SRQ Reviews

Best restaurant reviews in Sarasota Florida
Follow Me on Pinterest

Follow SRQ on
Follow SRQ on Facebook
Follow SRQ on Twitter 

Be part of the SRQ Review Network
Be part of the
SRQ Network
put our badge on your blog or website

Banner Photos by
Marcus Urban